heapreplace, methodcaller

[bearophileHUGS@lycos.com]

Hello, I'm experimenting more with Python 2.6 and its numerous
changes.

To improve name coherence I think this method of the heapq module:
heapq.heaprepla ce(heap, item)

can grow an alias in Python 2.6.1/2.7 and 3.0/3.1:
heapq.heappoppu sh(heap, item)

So later the heapreplace() name can be deprecated.

The heapq can also become a Heap class (with methods named as the
functions), with an optional key function; time ago I have written
such class in the cookbook.

----------

Regarding the operators module, this syntax:
methodcaller('r eplace', 'old', 'new')

Has this meaning:
lambda s: s.replace('old' , 'new')

I don't know if methodcaller() is faster than that lambda but:
- It's not shorter;
- For me it's not more readable;
- If it's faster than the lambda, then maybe CPython can start
performing a little more optimizations, like turning that tiny lambda
into inlined code.

Bye,
bearophile

[Marc 'BlackJack' Rintsch]

Re: heapreplace, methodcaller

On Sat, 18 Oct 2008 07:01:26 -0700, bearophileHUGS wrote:

Hello, I'm experimenting more with Python 2.6 and its numerous changes.
>
[…]
>
Regarding the operators module, this syntax: methodcaller('r eplace',
'old', 'new')
>
Has this meaning:
lambda s: s.replace('old' , 'new')
>
I don't know if methodcaller() is faster than that lambda but:
- It's not shorter;
- For me it's not more readable;

Then use the ``lambda``.

Your example has just literal constants. Let's take this example:

methodcaller(me th, arg_a, arg_b)

which is expressed as ``lambda`` function:

lambda x, m=meth, a=arg_a, b=arg_b: getattr(x, meth)(a, b)

Which is longer and IMHO less readable than `methodcaller() `.

- If it's faster than the lambda, then maybe CPython can start
performing a little more optimizations, like turning that tiny lambda
into inlined code.

How? The functions in `operator` are meant to be passed directly or to
to create other functions that are passed as HOFs into other functions.
So the compiler doesn't know in which functions they are used in the end
and it's possible that different functions are used there too.

Ciao,
Marc 'BlackJack' Rintsch

[Raymond Hettinger]

Re: heapreplace, methodcaller

On Oct 18, 7:01 am, bearophileH...@ lycos.com wrote:

To improve name coherence I think this method of the heapq module:
heapq.heaprepla ce(heap, item)
>
can grow an alias in Python 2.6.1/2.7 and 3.0/3.1:
heapq.heappoppu sh(heap, item)
>
So later the heapreplace() name can be deprecated.

Too late for 2.6 and possibly too late and too disruptive for 3.0
(which needs to minimize transitions from 2.6).


Raymond