Time Complexity of String Operations

[youtoo]

It has been extensively discussed the time complexity (quadratic) of
string concatenation (due to string's immutability).
But what is:

== the time complexity of string indexing? Is it constant?
== the time complexity of string slicing? Is it O(K) with K the
slice's length?

How are strings stored in Python? As arrays? As linked lists?

Thanks a lot!

yt.

[David Wahler]

Re: Time Complexity of String Operations

On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 10:31 PM, youtoo <you2000too@gma il.comwrote:

It has been extensively discussed the time complexity (quadratic) of
string concatenation (due to string's immutability).

Actually, it is roughly linear, at least for reasonable string lengths:

$ python -V
Python 2.5.2
$ python -mtimeit -s "n=1000; a='#'*n" "a+a"
1000000 loops, best of 3: 1 usec per loop
$ python -mtimeit -s "n=10000; a='#'*n" "a+a"
100000 loops, best of 3: 5.88 usec per loop
$ python -mtimeit -s "n=100000; a='#'*n" "a+a"
10000 loops, best of 3: 59.8 usec per loop

Repeatedly constructing a string by appending a constant number of
characters at a time, however, is quadratic in the final string length
(although VM optimizations may affect this).

But what is:
>
== the time complexity of string indexing? Is it constant?

Yes.

== the time complexity of string slicing? Is it O(K) with K the
slice's length?

I suspect so, since the time is dominated by the time taken to copy
the data into a new string object.

How are strings stored in Python? As arrays? As linked lists?

Arrays; see Include/stringobject.h in the Python source distribution.

-- David

[Terry Reedy]

Re: Time Complexity of String Operations



youtoo wrote:

It has been extensively discussed the time complexity (quadratic) of
string concatenation (due to string's immutability).
But what is:
>
== the time complexity of string indexing? Is it constant?
== the time complexity of string slicing? Is it O(K) with K the
slice's length?
>
How are strings stored in Python? As arrays? As linked lists?

There is a Py wiki page on such issues. A wiki search should find it.

[youtoo]

Re: Time Complexity of String Operations


On 22 jul, 01:39, "David Wahler" <dwah...@gmail. comwrote:

On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 10:31 PM, youtoo <you2000...@gma il.comwrote:

It has been extensively discussed the time complexity (quadratic) of
string concatenation (due to string's immutability).

>
Actually, it is roughly linear, at least for reasonable string lengths:
>
$ python -V
Python 2.5.2
$ python -mtimeit -s "n=1000; a='#'*n" "a+a"
1000000 loops, best of 3: 1 usec per loop
$ python -mtimeit -s "n=10000; a='#'*n" "a+a"
100000 loops, best of 3: 5.88 usec per loop
$ python -mtimeit -s "n=100000; a='#'*n" "a+a"
10000 loops, best of 3: 59.8 usec per loop
>
Repeatedly constructing a string by appending a constant number of
characters at a time, however, is quadratic in the final string length
(although VM optimizations may affect this).
>

But what is:

>

== the time complexity of string indexing? Is it constant?

>
Yes.
>

== the time complexity of string slicing? Is it O(K) with K the
slice's length?

>
I suspect so, since the time is dominated by the time taken to copy
the data into a new string object.
>

How are strings stored in Python? As arrays? As linked lists?

>
Arrays; see Include/stringobject.h in the Python source distribution.
>
-- David

Thank you very much!

yt.