string methods of a str subclass

[Daniel Nogradi]

I am probably misunderstandin g some basic issue here but this
behaviour is not what I would expect:



Python 2.4 (#1, Mar 22 2005, 21:42:42)
[GCC 3.3.5 20050117 (prerelease) (SUSE Linux)] on linux2
Type "help", "copyright" , "credits" or "license" for more information.

>>class mystr( str ):

.... pass
....

>>x = mystr( 'x' )
>>isinstance( x, mystr )

True

>>isinstance( x.strip( ), mystr )

False

>>>

Why is the strip( ) method returning something that is not a mystr
instance? I would expect all methods operating on a string instance
and returning another string instance to correctly operate on a mystr
instance and return a mystr instance. How would I achieve something
like this without manually copying all string returning methods from
str and stuffing the result to mystr( ) before returning?

[7stud]

Re: string methods of a str subclass

On Apr 16, 3:28 am, "Daniel Nogradi" <nogr...@gmail. comwrote:

I am probably misunderstandin g some basic issue here but this
behaviour is not what I would expect:
>
Python 2.4 (#1, Mar 22 2005, 21:42:42)
[GCC 3.3.5 20050117 (prerelease) (SUSE Linux)] on linux2
Type "help", "copyright" , "credits" or "license" for more information.>>c lass mystr( str ):
>
... pass
...
>

>x = mystr( 'x' )
>isinstance( x, mystr )

True

>isinstance( x.strip( ), mystr )

False
>
Why is the strip( ) method returning something that is not a mystr
instance? I would expect all methods operating on a string instance
and returning another string instance to correctly operate on a mystr
instance and return a mystr instance. How would I achieve something
like this without manually copying all string returning methods from
str and stuffing the result to mystr( ) before returning?

class A(object):
def __init__(self, s):
self.s = s
def strip(self):
return 2

class mystr(A):
pass

x = mystr("x")
print isinstance(x, mystr)
print isinstance(x.st rip(), mystr)

[Duncan Booth]

Re: string methods of a str subclass

"Daniel Nogradi" <nogradi@gmail. comwrote:

Why is the strip( ) method returning something that is not a mystr
instance? I would expect all methods operating on a string instance
and returning another string instance to correctly operate on a mystr
instance and return a mystr instance.

Why would you expect that?
Would you expect the __str__ and__repr__ methods also to return a mystr
instance? If not those, then which other ones might also be excluded?
Is x.encode('zip') still a mystr instance or an encoded byte-string?

How would I achieve something
like this without manually copying all string returning methods from
str and stuffing the result to mystr( ) before returning?

You don't without wrapping all the affected methods. It doesn't need to
involve manual copying though: you have a programming language available so
just write a list of method names and then some code to wrap them
automatically.

[7stud]

Re: string methods of a str subclass

On Apr 16, 3:28 am, "Daniel Nogradi" <nogr...@gmail. comwrote:

I would expect all methods operating on a string instance
and returning another string instance

Ok, then this:

class A(object):
def __init__(self, s):
self.s = s
def strip(self):
return self.s

class mystr(A):
pass

x = mystr("x")
print isinstance(x, mystr)
print isinstance(x.st rip(), mystr)


"x" is a string, and that is what gets passed to the base class's
__init__ method, and that is what strip() operates on.

[Daniel Nogradi]

Re: string methods of a str subclass

Why is the strip( ) method returning something that is not a mystr

instance? I would expect all methods operating on a string instance
and returning another string instance to correctly operate on a mystr
instance and return a mystr instance.

>
Why would you expect that?
Would you expect the __str__ and__repr__ methods also to return a mystr
instance? If not those, then which other ones might also be excluded?
Is x.encode('zip') still a mystr instance or an encoded byte-string?

Okay, good point, thanks.

How would I achieve something
like this without manually copying all string returning methods from
str and stuffing the result to mystr( ) before returning?

>
You don't without wrapping all the affected methods. It doesn't need to
involve manual copying though: you have a programming language available so
just write a list of method names and then some code to wrap them
automatically.

Yes, this is in fact what I am doing, using __getattr__ and such. Thanks again.