Weird behavior in search in a list

[Su Y]

hi all,
I can't understand how this code work, its behavior is really weird
for me...

I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, so
I wrote:
def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem<num:
count+=1
return count

I found that if extend[] is monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5,
5.6],
it works fine: find(4) returns 3, extend[3] is 4.5.
But, if extend[] is not monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5, 5.6,
4.6, 3.4, 2.1, 0.3],
find(4) returns 6, extend[6] is 3.4!

what's going on here? I really can't understand....

[Su Y]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list

On 3ÔÂ29ÈÕ, ÏÂÎç7ʱ51·Ö, "Su Y" <suyua...@gmail .comwrote:

hi all,
I can't understand how this code work, its behavior is really weird
for me...
>
I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, soI wrote:
>
def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem<num:
count+=1
return count
>
I found that if extend[] is monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5,
5.6],
it works fine: find(4) returns 3, extend[3] is 4.5.
But, if extend[] is not monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5, 5.6,
4.6, 3.4, 2.1, 0.3],
find(4) returns 6, extend[6] is 3.4!
>
what's going on here? I really can't understand....

and I am using Python 2.5 on WinXP.

[Amit Khemka]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list

On 29 Mar 2007 04:51:00 -0700, Su Y <suyuancn@gmail .comwrote:

hi all,
I can't understand how this code work, its behavior is really weird
for me...
>
I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, so
I wrote:
def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem<num:
count+=1
return count
>
I found that if extend[] is monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5,
5.6],
it works fine: find(4) returns 3, extend[3] is 4.5.
But, if extend[] is not monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5, 5.6,
4.6, 3.4, 2.1, 0.3],
find(4) returns 6, extend[6] is 3.4!
>
what's going on here? I really can't understand....

Actually your function "find" returns the number of elements in list
extend, which are smaller than the argument. Perhaps you wanted to
'break' when once the condition is met.

def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem>num: break
else: count+=1
return count

Btw a concise way could be:
def getfirstbigger( num):
for i,x in enumerate(exten d):
if x>num: return i
return len(extend)

HTH,


--
----
Amit Khemka -- onyomo.com
Home Page: www.cse.iitd.ernet.in/~csd00377
Endless the world's turn, endless the sun's Spinning, Endless the quest;
I turn again, back to my own beginning, And here, find rest.

[Amit Khemka]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list

On 29 Mar 2007 04:51:00 -0700, Su Y <suyuancn@gmail .comwrote:
<snip>

I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, so

<snip>

On 3/29/07, Amit Khemka <khemkaamit@gma il.comwrote:
Btw a concise way could be:
def getfirstbigger( num):
for i,x in enumerate(exten d):
if x>num: return i
return len(extend)

I forgot to add that you can as well 'return' the the item (along with
the index), but in case all the items in the list are smaller than the
argument, what return value do you require?
--
----
Amit Khemka -- onyomo.com
Home Page: www.cse.iitd.ernet.in/~csd00377
Endless the world's turn, endless the sun's Spinning, Endless the quest;
I turn again, back to my own beginning, And here, find rest.

[Josh]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list


"Su Y" <suyuancn@gmail .comwrote in message
news:1175169306 .021284.46270@e 65g2000hsc.goog legroups.com...
On 3ÔÂ29ÈÕ, ÏÂÎç7ʱ51·Ö, "Su Y" <suyua...@gmail .comwrote:

hi all,
I can't understand how this code work, its behavior is really weird
for me...
>
I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, soI
wrote:
>
def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem<num:
count+=1

else:
break

return count
>

you need to break out of the loop when you first encounter num>elem. The
reason it works in your sorted list scenario is because elem will be num,
always, after some point. It won't be in your unsorted list.

I've added the else: break in your code above
j

[Michael Bentley]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list


On Mar 29, 2007, at 6:51 AM, Su Y wrote:

>
I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, so
I wrote:
def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem<num:
count+=1
return count
>
I found that if extend[] is monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5,
5.6],
it works fine: find(4) returns 3, extend[3] is 4.5.
But, if extend[] is not monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5, 5.6,
4.6, 3.4, 2.1, 0.3],
find(4) returns 6, extend[6] is 3.4!
>
what's going on here? I really can't understand....

find() loops through the list, and every time it finds a value less
than num it increments count. So in your second example the values
1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 3.4, 2.1, and 0.3 are all less than 4, which means
count will be 6.

As you learned, a sorted list behaves as you expect. So one approach
is to sort your list first. But another perhaps better approach is
to do something like:

def find(num):
# check to make sure there *is* a value greater than num
if max(extend) num:
# then return the smallest value that is greater than num
return min([x for x in extend if x num])
else:
return None

Hope this helps,
Michael

[Amit Khemka]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list

On 3/29/07, Michael Bentley <michael@jedimi ndworks.comwrot e:

>
On Mar 29, 2007, at 6:51 AM, Su Y wrote:

I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, so

<snip>

def find(num):
# check to make sure there *is* a value greater than num
if max(extend) num:
# then return the smallest value that is greater than num
return min([x for x in extend if x num])
else:
return None

I think OP wants the first value in the list greater than 'num' not
the smallest greater value in the list.

cheers,
--
----
Amit Khemka -- onyomo.com
Home Page: www.cse.iitd.ernet.in/~csd00377
Endless the world's turn, endless the sun's Spinning, Endless the quest;
I turn again, back to my own beginning, And here, find rest.

[Su Y]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list

On 3ÔÂ29ÈÕ, ÏÂÎç8ʱ22·Ö, Michael Bentley <mich...@jedimi ndworks.comwrot e:

On Mar 29, 2007, at 6:51 AM, Su Y wrote:
>
>
>
>
>

I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, so
I wrote:
def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem<num:
count+=1
return count

>

I found that if extend[] is monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5,
5.6],
it works fine: find(4) returns 3, extend[3] is 4.5.
But, if extend[] is not monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5, 5.6,
4.6, 3.4, 2.1, 0.3],
find(4) returns 6, extend[6] is 3.4!

>

what's going on here? I really can't understand....

>
find() loops through the list, and every time it finds a value less
than num it increments count. So in your second example the values
1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 3.4, 2.1, and 0.3 are all less than 4, which means
count will be 6.
>
As you learned, a sorted list behaves as you expect. So one approach
is to sort your list first. But another perhaps better approach is
to do something like:
>
def find(num):
# check to make sure there *is* a value greater than num
if max(extend) num:
# then return the smallest value that is greater than num
return min([x for x in extend if x num])
else:
return None
>
Hope this helps,
Michael

oh yes, it's the "break" I forgot... Thank you, it helps me a lot!

[Hendrik van Rooyen]

Re: Weird behavior in search in a list

"Su Y" <s...ncn@gmail. comwrote:

I want find the first number in extend[] which is larger than num, so
I wrote:
def find(num):
count=0
for elem in extend:
if elem<num:
count+=1
return count
>
I found that if extend[] is monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5,
5.6],
it works fine: find(4) returns 3, extend[3] is 4.5.
But, if extend[] is not monotonous, like [1.1, 2.3, 3.2, 4.5, 5.6,
4.6, 3.4, 2.1, 0.3],
find(4) returns 6, extend[6] is 3.4!
>
what's going on here? I really can't understand....

Hint: extend[0] is1.1
Hint: extend[7] is 2.1
Hint: 2.1 is less than 4

You have to stop counting and come out of the loop when you find the
first one - what your function is doing is counting the elements less than
num, not finding the first one that is.

hth - Hendrik