[perl-python] text pattern matching, and expressiveness

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Xah Lee

    #1

    [perl-python] text pattern matching, and expressiveness

    20050207 text pattern matching

    # -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
    # Python

    # suppose you want to replace all strings of the form
    # <img src="some.gif" width="30" height="20">
    # to
    # <img src="some.png" width="30" height="20">
    # in your html files.

    # you can use the "re" module.

    import re

    text = r'''<html>
    blab blab
    <P> look at this <img src="./some.gif" width="30" height="20"> pict
    and this one <img class="float-right" src="../that.gif">, both are
    beautiful, but also look: <img src ="my.gif">, and sequel
    <img src=
    "girl.gif"> yeah! </p>
    '''

    new = re.sub(r'''src\ s*=\s*"([^"]+)\.gif"''', r'''src="\1.png "''',
    text)

    print new

    # the first argument to re.sub is a regex pattern.
    # the second argument is the replacement string,
    # which can contain captured pattern (the \1)
    # the third argument is the text to be checked.
    # an optional 4th argument is number of replacement
    # to make. If ommitted, it replace all occurances of matches.

    # see
    # http://python.org/doc/lib/module-re.html

    --------------------
    # similar code in perl is s///. For example,
    $text = "123";
    $text =~ s/2/9/;
    print $text;

    ----------------------
    In languages human or computer, there's a notion of expressiveness.

    English for example, is very expressive in manifestation, witness all
    the poetry and implications and allusions and connotations and
    dictions. There are a myriad ways to say one thing, fuzzy and warm and
    all. But when we look at what things it can say, its power of
    expression with respect to meaning, or its efficiency or precision, we
    find natural languages incapable.

    These can be felt thru several means. A sure way is thru logic,
    linguistics, and or what's called Philosophy of Languages. One can also
    glean directly the incapacity and inadequacy of natural languages by
    studying the artificial language lojban, where one realizes, not only
    are natural languages incapable in precision and lacking in efficiency,
    but simply a huge number of things are near impossible to express thru
    them.

    One thing commonly misunderstood in computing industry is the notion of
    expressiveness. If a language has a vocabulary of (smile, laugh, grin,
    giggle, chuckle, guffaw, cackle), then that language will not be as
    expressive, as a language with just (severe, slight, laugh, cry). The
    former is "expressive " in terms of fluff, where the latter is
    expressive with respect to meaning.

    Similarly, in computer languages, expressiveness is significant with
    respect to semantics, not syntactical variation.

    These two contrasting ideas can be easily seen thru Perl vs Python
    languages, and as one specific example of their text pattern matching
    abilities.

    Perl is a language of syntactical variegations. Python on the other
    hand, does not even allow changes in code's indentation, but its
    efficiency and power in expression, with respect to semantics (i.e.
    algorithms), showcases Perl's poverty in specification.

    Xah
    xah@xahlee.org


  • John Bokma

    #2
    Re: [perl-python] text pattern matching, and expressiveness

    Xah Lee wrote:
    [color=blue]
    > Perl is a language of syntactical variegations. Python on the other
    > hand, does not even allow changes in code's indentation, but its
    > efficiency and power in expression, with respect to semantics (i.e.
    > algorithms), showcases Perl's poverty in specification.[/color]

    Clarify :-D.

    --
    John Small Perl scripts: http://johnbokma.com/perl/
    Perl programmer available: http://castleamber.com/
    Happy Customers: http://castleamber.com/testimonials.html

    Comment

    • Daniel Fackrell

      #3
      Re: [perl-python] text pattern matching, and expressiveness

      "John Bokma" <postmaster@cas tleamber.com> wrote in message
      news:Xns95F6917 BFEEF4castleamb er@130.133.1.4. ..[color=blue]
      > Xah Lee wrote:
      >[color=green]
      > > Perl is a language of syntactical variegations. Python on the other
      > > hand, does not even allow changes in code's indentation, but its
      > > efficiency and power in expression, with respect to semantics (i.e.
      > > algorithms), showcases Perl's poverty in specification.[/color]
      >
      > Clarify :-D.[/color]

      Clarification:

      He (XL) is a troll and admits it. If only he would include that information
      up-front in his (IMO worthless) [perl-python] posts, it would save a lot of
      effort.

      Daniel Fackrell



      Comment

      • Diez B. Roggisch

        #4
        Re: [perl-python] text pattern matching, and expressiveness

        > He (XL) is a troll and admits it. If only he would include that[color=blue]
        > information up-front in his (IMO worthless) [perl-python] posts, it would
        > save a lot of effort.[/color]

        He does - all of his posts start with [perl-python]. Now the big question is
        which community comes up with a better/nicer/shorter/whatever filter -
        pythonistas or perljunkies.

        --
        Regards,

        Diez B. Roggisch

        Comment

        • Aaron Sherman

          #5
          Re: [perl-python] text pattern matching, and expressiveness

          John Bokma wrote:[color=blue]
          > Xah Lee wrote:[/color]
          [color=blue][color=green]
          >>Perl is a language of syntactical variegations. Python on the other
          >>hand, does not even allow changes in code's indentation, but its
          >>efficiency and power in expression, with respect to semantics (i.e.
          >>algorithms) , showcases Perl's poverty in specification.[/color][/color]
          [color=blue]
          > Clarify :-D.[/color]

          Well, I think it's pretty clearly troll-bait. Semantics != algorithms
          and Perl (just like Python) has no such poverty WRT specification.

          Sounds like someone who learned Python and forgot that it wasn't a
          religion. Too bad, but a disease unique to no particular language. Perl,
          Python, Ruby, C, APL, LISP... they've all had their unpleasant zealots.

          Comment

          Working...