(long message)Request advie on an app I'm doing

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Benjamin

    #1

    (long message)Request advie on an app I'm doing

    Hello,
    I need some advice on a financial application I'm doing. First, I suppose
    I should give a little background so you know where I'm coming from. For
    5 years I earned my living doing COBOL programming with some occasional
    VB and web programming with ASP. Prior to that I went to a technical
    college where I took a couple of courses in c, c++ and pascal. Although
    now about all I can do is the basic "hello world" type applications in
    them, also I never really grasped oop. Which is one of the reasons I want
    to learn python, as it seems to be the easiest language to learn oop
    with. For the last 2 years, I've been earning my living trading, at first
    stocks and futures, now it's mainly all forex (foreign exchange), thus
    the need for this app.

    Anyway the app. I'm doing is a forex charting, backtesting and
    eventually/hopefully be able to autotrade (it'd also be nice to implement
    a neural network), also I figure that this will be good way to learn
    other programming languages as eventually I plan to rewrite this in c,
    c++ and Java (and possibly assembler, just cause I like to torture myself
    ;) ). Basically it's something along the lines of Wealth lab:
    http://www.wealth-lab.com/ or Tradestation: http://www.tradestation.com/
    but one that will run on linux as well as windows (actually it'll be a
    combination of several trading programs, basically all the features I
    like with none of the ones that annoy me).

    Heres the application implementation proces:
    Phase I - design and implement a MySQL database
    Phase II - import/export a flatfile into the database
    Phase III - add networking to retrieve historical data via dukascopy
    Phase IV - add realtime networking to retrieve real-time data via
    dukascopy
    Phase V - design and implement gui (minus the charting)
    Phase V1 - add charting
    Phase VII - add indicators
    Phase VIII - add scripting capability
    Phase IX - add backtesting
    Phase X - add paper-trading
    Phase XI - add auto-paper-trading
    Phase XII - add program, database, and internet connection redundancy
    Phase XIII - add data-feed redundancy with E-signal and oanda
    Phase XIV - implement real auto-trading with oanda and gain
    Phase XV - add Futures, stocks and options (nice but optional)
    Phase XVI - add Futures, stocks and options auto-trading with IB and
    Mytrack (nice but optional
    Phase XVII - implement Neural Network (nice but somewhat optional)

    When I was designing this I thought that the scripting capability would
    actually be the toughest thing but since I learned about eval() and exec
    () that should be fairly trivial (this was actually a very pleasant
    surprise with python for me). Now the most difficult parts as I see it is
    going to be the gui (particularly the charting), the redundancy, and the
    neural network (this will be the toughest but put off till last because
    without the rest in place there's really just no point in having it,
    which is also why it's somewhat optional).

    Phases 1 and 2 are done phase 3 will be done today and phase 4 will be
    done this weekend. Which brings me to my questions. First I need to know
    which gui toolkit, I should use. The requirements are basically stability
    on both linux and windows, and it needs to have some type of canvas or
    picturebox control (or widget is what I think the term is in python), so
    I can draw the graphs. Also it needs to have a splitter, and toolbar
    widget. From what I've seen it look like the major gui toolkits are:
    tkinter (of course), wxpython, pyqt (actually I have doubts about this as
    I just don't like the license), pygtk, pyfltk, fxpy, and pyopengl. What I
    need to know is whether you think one of the above is suitable for my
    app., given the requirements, how stable it is, how easy it is to
    implement, whether docs are available (ie. tutorials and preferably a
    book or two), and how easy it is to learn (although this is the least of
    my concerns), also I need to know if you think speed will be a concern as
    I plan to be able to graph at least 10000 timeframes of data with
    probably 6 - 10 indicators so figure it will need to draw something like
    100,000 - 200,000 points/lines/ boxes etc for every 10,000 periods.

    I'd also like to know if there's any suitable financial chart widget out
    there that does candlestick, ohlc, point and figure, and 3-line break
    charts, etc., I've looked but the only one I've come across is Chart
    Director: http://www.advsofteng.com/product.html and I find it to be
    unsuitable, actually what I really need something like the StockChart X
    activex control: http://www.modulusfe.com/stockchartx/

    Finally, and this is just planning for the later stage, I'm wondering if
    anyone has any ideas on how I can implement the program redundancy. Right
    now I'm thinking of having the program run on about 6 or 7 computers with
    with every two hooked up to a different internet connection, ie the main
    group would be connected to a t-1 line, the next group connected to a
    cable line, the next connected to dsl, next connected to a isdn line and
    then finally one connected to a regular modem. The thing with this is
    that, I don't see any problem with having them talk to each other or
    perhaps set up a table in the database with two fields:
    CurrentTradingC omp and LastTime, and then just have the current program
    update that table every 10 seconds, and then have every program check the
    table every 30 secs or so and if the first goes down then have the second
    take over, then the third etc. That's not a problem, what I'm wondering
    is whether or not (and if so how) python can dial the modem on the final
    computer, or even if it's a good idea to even have the programs wait till
    the one connected to the modem becomes the main computer, (I'll have to
    think about that) anyway's I'm rambling but if anyone has any comments or
    suggestions, on this I'd love to hear them.

    Sorry for the long message, but I figured it would be better to give all
    of the information you might need rather than leave some vital piece out.

    Thanks,
    Ben
    ps - if you want to email me then just take out the numbers in my return
    address

    x-- 100 Proof News - http://www.100ProofNews.com
    x-- 3,500+ Binary NewsGroups, and over 90,000 other groups
    x-- Access to over 800 Gigs/Day - $8.95/Month
    x-- UNLIMITED DOWNLOAD

  • Steve Lamb

    #2
    Re: (long message)Request advie on an app I'm doing

    On 2003-09-12, Benjamin <2benjnse231@sa fe-mail.net> wrote:[color=blue]
    > Which brings me to my questions. First I need to know which gui
    > toolkit, I should use. The requirements are basically stability on
    > both linux and windows, and it needs to have some type of canvas or
    > picturebox control (or widget is what I think the term is in python),
    > so I can draw the graphs. Also it needs to have a splitter, and
    > toolbar widget. From what I've seen it look like the major gui
    > toolkits are: tkinter (of course), wxpython, pyqt (actually I have
    > doubts about this as I just don't like the license), pygtk, pyfltk,
    > fxpy, and pyopengl.[/color]

    Take a look at wxPython. It is a wrapper around wxWindows which an
    excellent cross platform (Windows/*Nix) set of Libs. It uses GTK on
    Linux and Windows native on the Windows side. Also there is an
    excellent RAD tool for wxPython, Boa-Constructor. The author took his
    inspiration from Delphi and applied it to wxPython. Very easy to use,
    very fast designing of GUI elements.

    --
    Steve C. Lamb | I'm your priest, I'm your shrink, I'm your
    PGP Key: 8B6E99C5 | main connection to the switchboard of souls.
    -------------------------------+---------------------------------------------

    Comment

    • Chris Liechti

      #3
      Re: (long message)Request advie on an app I'm doing

      Steve Lamb <grey@despair.d miyu.org> wrote in
      news:slrnbm4lmu .as0.grey@dmiyu .org:
      [color=blue]
      > On 2003-09-12, Benjamin <2benjnse231@sa fe-mail.net> wrote:[color=green]
      >> Which brings me to my questions. First I need to know which gui
      >> toolkit, I should use. The requirements are basically stability on
      >> both linux and windows, and it needs to have some type of canvas or
      >> picturebox control (or widget is what I think the term is in python),
      >> so I can draw the graphs. Also it needs to have a splitter, and
      >> toolbar widget. From what I've seen it look like the major gui
      >> toolkits are: tkinter (of course), wxpython, pyqt (actually I have
      >> doubts about this as I just don't like the license), pygtk, pyfltk,
      >> fxpy, and pyopengl.[/color]
      >
      > Take a look at wxPython. It is a wrapper around wxWindows which an
      > excellent cross platform (Windows/*Nix) set of Libs. It uses GTK on
      > Linux and Windows native on the Windows side. Also there is an
      > excellent RAD tool for wxPython, Boa-Constructor. The author took his
      > inspiration from Delphi and applied it to wxPython. Very easy to use,
      > very fast designing of GUI elements.[/color]

      yes, boa is nice. but i like to use SciTe as editor for all kinds of source
      files (instead of an IDE) and i prefer wxGlade as GUI editor. wxGlade does
      not support binding events, like boa, but it's a great and fast way to
      design a GUI with sizers (you can even update the source file later, it
      keeps you code and updates the gui part)

      chris

      --
      Chris <cliechti@gmx.n et>

      Comment

      • John J. Lee

        #4
        Re: (long message)Request advie on an app I'm doing

        Benjamin <2benjnse231@sa fe-mail.net> writes:

        [...][color=blue]
        > When I was designing this I thought that the scripting capability would
        > actually be the toughest thing but since I learned about eval() and exec
        > () that should be fairly trivial (this was actually a very pleasant
        > surprise with python for me). Now the most difficult parts as I see it is[/color]
        [...]

        Why do you think you need eval or exec? If it's all in Python ('pure
        Python'), a 'script' is just a Python program that imports stuff from
        your libraries and does whatever is required.

        If it's not all in Python, it's usually easiest to wrap the non-Python
        bits for Python access so you can just import them too (with eg. SWIG,
        Pyrex or Boost.Python), and write scripts exactly as if everything
        were pure Python (or, in the case of Java, just use Jython).

        Another way, attractive if you want to write scripts in multiple
        languages (not just Python), is to use a component framework like
        CORBA or XPCOM (or UNO, or KParts, or Bonobo, or MS COM...sigh).


        John

        Comment

        • Steve Lamb

          #5
          Re: (long message)Request advie on an app I'm doing

          On 2003-09-12, Chris Liechti <cliechti@gmx.n et> wrote:[color=blue]
          > yes, boa is nice. but i like to use SciTe as editor for all kinds of source
          > files (instead of an IDE) and i prefer wxGlade as GUI editor. wxGlade does
          > not support binding events, like boa, but it's a great and fast way to
          > design a GUI with sizers (you can even update the source file later, it
          > keeps you code and updates the gui part)[/color]

          Boa does this. Well, mostly. You cannot touch pregenerated areas
          with code it doesn't know about. As time goes by it knows about more
          and more code. It will warn you if you're editing a portion of code
          that contains pieces it doesn't know about. Boa also does sizers.


          --
          Steve C. Lamb | I'm your priest, I'm your shrink, I'm your
          PGP Key: 8B6E99C5 | main connection to the switchboard of souls.
          -------------------------------+---------------------------------------------

          Comment

          Working...