Objective evidence comparing languages?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • David Mathog

    #1

    Objective evidence comparing languages?

    I'm looking for studies that objectively compare various languages to
    measure the following attributes:

    1. Ease of writing new code (better== faster, better==fewer bugs).
    2. Ease of maintaining existing code.
    3. Portability.
    4. Time to learn language "adequately ".
    5. Speed of resulting code.

    The last time I saw such a study was almost 10 years ago, compared only
    C and Ada, and was found here:



    That URL is long dead but the contents are still available from the URL
    via the wayback machine at http://www.archive.org.

    Where are the recent equivalent studies?

    Please, nobody reply with "X is better than Y because..." - I'm not
    looking for opinions, I'm searching for studies that objectively
    demonstrate the differences between languages.

    Thanks,

    David Mathog
    mathog@caltech. edu



  • Stavros Christoforou

    #2
    Re: Objective evidence comparing languages?

    David Mathog wrote:[color=blue]
    > I'm looking for studies that objectively compare various languages to
    > measure the following attributes:
    >
    > 1. Ease of writing new code (better== faster, better==fewer bugs).
    > 2. Ease of maintaining existing code.
    > 3. Portability.
    > 4. Time to learn language "adequately ".
    > 5. Speed of resulting code.
    > ...[/color]
    [color=blue]
    > Please, nobody reply with "X is better than Y because..." - I'm not
    > looking for opinions, I'm searching for studies that objectively
    > demonstrate the differences between languages.
    >[/color]

    What you are asking for is impossible, because of the points you are
    looking for. Points 1 and 4 depend of the programmer and their way of
    thinking (type of education plays a major role here), point 5 depends on
    the application and point 2 depends on the foresight and skills of the
    original programmer. The only real comparison can be done for point 3.

    Stavros

    Comment

    • Eric Sosman

      #3
      Re: Objective evidence comparing languages?



      David Mathog wrote On 11/10/05 11:02,:[color=blue]
      > I'm looking for studies that objectively compare various languages to
      > measure the following attributes:
      >
      > 1. Ease of writing new code (better== faster, better==fewer bugs).
      > 2. Ease of maintaining existing code.
      > 3. Portability.
      > 4. Time to learn language "adequately ".
      > 5. Speed of resulting code.[/color]

      A CACM article from about, oh, maybe six years ago
      compared C, C++, and Java on a couple of these measures.
      Sorry for the imprecision of the reference.

      --
      Eric.Sosman@sun .com

      Comment

      • Malcolm

        #4
        Re: Objective evidence comparing languages?


        "David Mathog" <mathog@caltech .edu> wrote[color=blue]
        > I'm looking for studies that objectively compare various languages to
        > measure the following attributes:
        >
        > 1. Ease of writing new code (better== faster, better==fewer bugs).
        > 2. Ease of maintaining existing code.
        > 3. Portability.
        > 4. Time to learn language "adequately ".
        > 5. Speed of resulting code.
        >
        > The last time I saw such a study was almost 10 years ago, compared only C
        > and Ada, and was found here:
        >
        > http://www.rational.com/support/tech...c_and_ada.html
        >
        > That URL is long dead but the contents are still available from the URL
        > via the wayback machine at http://www.archive.org.
        >
        > Where are the recent equivalent studies?
        >
        > Please, nobody reply with "X is better than Y because..." - I'm not
        > looking for opinions, I'm searching for studies that objectively
        > demonstrate the differences between languages.
        >[/color]
        It's very hard to come up with an objective metric.

        For instance, for criterion 1, are you looking at university undergraduates,
        programmers in fairly routine commercial systems type jobs, scientific
        programmers, programmers for orgainisations like IBM?
        If we choose the first, do we mean computer science graduates from top
        universities, or are we talking about physicists and biologists who want to
        do a little bit of programming as a supplement to their main interest?



        Comment

        • Jack Klein

          #5
          Re: Objective evidence comparing languages?

          On Thu, 10 Nov 2005 08:02:24 -0800, David Mathog <mathog@caltech .edu>
          wrote in comp.lang.c:
          [color=blue]
          > I'm looking for studies that objectively compare various languages to
          > measure the following attributes:
          >
          > 1. Ease of writing new code (better== faster, better==fewer bugs).
          > 2. Ease of maintaining existing code.
          > 3. Portability.
          > 4. Time to learn language "adequately ".
          > 5. Speed of resulting code.
          >
          > The last time I saw such a study was almost 10 years ago, compared only
          > C and Ada, and was found here:
          >
          > http://www.rational.com/support/tech...c_and_ada.html
          >
          > That URL is long dead but the contents are still available from the URL
          > via the wayback machine at http://www.archive.org.
          >
          > Where are the recent equivalent studies?
          >
          > Please, nobody reply with "X is better than Y because..." - I'm not
          > looking for opinions, I'm searching for studies that objectively
          > demonstrate the differences between languages.
          >
          > Thanks,[/color]

          Learn how to use a proper signature line, please.

          Your question is off-topic in all three groups that you cross-posted
          it to. Language comparisons in language specific groups tend to
          quickly degenerate into advocacy and flames. And of course, C++ and
          Java are off-topic in comp.lang.c, Java at least is off-topic in
          comp.lang.c++, etc.

          If you are looking for a serious discussion I would suggest
          comp.programmin g and comp.software.e ng as your best candidates.

          --
          Jack Klein
          Home: http://JK-Technology.Com
          FAQs for
          comp.lang.c http://www.eskimo.com/~scs/C-faq/top.html
          comp.lang.c++ http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lite/
          alt.comp.lang.l earn.c-c++

          Comment

          Working...