overloading < and >

[johnmmcparland]

Hi all,

I know it is possible to overload the operators and < in C++ but how
can I do this.

Assume I have a class Date with three int members, m_day, m_month and
m_year. In the .cpp files I have defined the < and operators;

bool Date::operator< (const Date& d)
{
return
// this year < d year
(m_year < d.m_year) ||
// this year == d year and this month < d month
(m_year == d.m_year && m_month < d.m_month) ||
// this year == d year and this month == d month but
// this day < d day
(m_year == d.m_year && m_month == d.m_month &&
m_day < d.m_day);
}

bool Date::operator> (const Date& d)
{
return (d < (*this));
}

but my compiler informs me that those operators cannot be overloaded.
I will assume this is because I have not used the correct syntax as a
quick Google search on operator overloading will quickly show you that
these operators are not two of the few you cannot overload.

Could someone explain how I should overload these operators (and also
the >= and <= operators) and why I get this compiler error?

Thanks,

John

[p.lepin@ctncorp.com]

Re: overloading &lt; and &gt;

On Mar 26, 5:05 pm, "johnmmcparland "
<johnmmcparl... @googlemail.com wrote:

bool Date::operator< (const Date& d)
{

[implementation]

}
>
bool Date::operator> (const Date& d)
{
return (d < (*this));
}
>
but my compiler informs me that those operators cannot be
overloaded.

I'm not sure what's the problem with your compiler, but
you're trying to use a const reference in a non-const
context. After I made those operators const, g++ 4.1.2
compiled the test code without problem.

--
Pavel Lepin

[Rolf Magnus]

Re: overloading &lt; and &gt;

johnmmcparland wrote:

Hi all,
>
I know it is possible to overload the operators and < in C++ but how
can I do this.
>
Assume I have a class Date with three int members, m_day, m_month and
m_year. In the .cpp files I have defined the < and operators;
>
bool Date::operator< (const Date& d)

This should be:

bool Date::operator< (const Date& d) const

{
return
// this year < d year
(m_year < d.m_year) ||
// this year == d year and this month < d month
(m_year == d.m_year && m_month < d.m_month) ||
// this year == d year and this month == d month but
// this day < d day
(m_year == d.m_year && m_month == d.m_month &&
m_day < d.m_day);
}
>
bool Date::operator> (const Date& d)

bool Date::operator> (const Date& d) const

{
return (d < (*this));
}
>
but my compiler informs me that those operators cannot be overloaded.

What's the exact error message, and to which line does it belong?

I will assume this is because I have not used the correct syntax as a
quick Google search on operator overloading will quickly show you that
these operators are not two of the few you cannot overload.

They can be overloaded.

Could someone explain how I should overload these operators (and also
the >= and <= operators) and why I get this compiler error?

You didn't give enough information. You should give a minimal, but complete
program along with the error message produced by the compiler.

[johnmmcparland]

Re: overloading &lt; and &gt;

On 26 Mar, 15:53, Rolf Magnus <ramag...@t-online.dewrote:

johnmmcparland wrote:

Hi all,

>

I know it is possible to overload the operators and < in C++ but how
can I do this.

>

Assume I have a class Date with three int members, m_day, m_month and
m_year. In the .cpp files I have defined the < and operators;

>

bool Date::operator< (const Date& d)

>
This should be:
>
bool Date::operator< (const Date& d) const
>

{
return
// this year < d year
(m_year < d.m_year) ||
// this year == d year and this month < d month
(m_year == d.m_year && m_month < d.m_month) ||
// this year == d year and this month == d month but
// this day < d day
(m_year == d.m_year && m_month == d.m_month &&
m_day < d.m_day);
}

>

bool Date::operator> (const Date& d)

>
bool Date::operator> (const Date& d) const
>

{
return (d < (*this));
}

>

but my compiler informs me that those operators cannot be overloaded.

>
What's the exact error message, and to which line does it belong?
>

I will assume this is because I have not used the correct syntax as a
quick Google search on operator overloading will quickly show you that
these operators are not two of the few you cannot overload.

>
They can be overloaded.
>

Could someone explain how I should overload these operators (and also
the >= and <= operators) and why I get this compiler error?

>
You didn't give enough information. You should give a minimal, but complete
program along with the error message produced by the compiler.

Hmm my previous post doesn't seem to have got here.

In it I had explained my problem much clearer and provided a nice
compact example but in the process of retyping I found the problem I
was having was to do with the fact I defined the < operator twice in
my header file. D'oh!