Re: Comparing two numbers
On Wed, 19 Jan 2005 14:35:41 +0000, Chris Dollin wrote:
....
[color=blue][color=green]
>> I counted a, b and c as three items.[/color]
>
> Those are the *names* of the items.[/color]
Correct, the items themselves are the three objects/variables these
represent.
[color=blue]
> The items are 42 and 17.[/color]
Those are properties of the items. It just happens that two items share
the same property. That does not make them the same item. I have 3 coins
in my hand which I will label x, y and z. The fact that x and z are of the
same denomination does not suddenly mean that I only have 2 coins in my
hand.
[color=blue]
> Otherwise
> the answer would likely be "c" ...[/color]
When you use a comparative or superlative form you are comparing a common
property, usually as defined by the base adjective. The assumption here
was the property in question "great-ness" was the value, but that may be a
wrong assumption. If so the fault is in the question for not being clear.
Lawrence
On Wed, 19 Jan 2005 14:35:41 +0000, Chris Dollin wrote:
....
[color=blue][color=green]
>> I counted a, b and c as three items.[/color]
>
> Those are the *names* of the items.[/color]
Correct, the items themselves are the three objects/variables these
represent.
[color=blue]
> The items are 42 and 17.[/color]
Those are properties of the items. It just happens that two items share
the same property. That does not make them the same item. I have 3 coins
in my hand which I will label x, y and z. The fact that x and z are of the
same denomination does not suddenly mean that I only have 2 coins in my
hand.
[color=blue]
> Otherwise
> the answer would likely be "c" ...[/color]
When you use a comparative or superlative form you are comparing a common
property, usually as defined by the base adjective. The assumption here
was the property in question "great-ness" was the value, but that may be a
wrong assumption. If so the fault is in the question for not being clear.
Lawrence
Comment