Whats missing from postgresql

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Anthony_Barker

    #1

    Whats missing from postgresql

    Aberdeen has a review of open source rdbms. The overall review was
    quite positive but mentioned a few things missing.


    Features desired according to users:
    Gui control centre
    Improved Replication
    Two-phase commit


    They list what they think is missing from postgresql compared with
    Oracle/db2/MSSQL

    PostgreSQL does not offer the following key features typically
    provided in enterprise databases(accor ding to Aberdeen):
    • Incremental and parallel backup/restore
    • Encryption (security)
    • Deadlock detection
    • Row-level locking (typically required by large packaged
    applications) —
    although PostgreSQL does offer alternative sub-table locking schemes
    • Bit-mapped indexing (for large data warehouses)
    • A single GUI administrative interface
    • View update/insert/delete


    I was pretty sure that NETAPP offers incremental backup of Postgresql
    - but perhaps I'm wrong.

    What about the row level locking or the other features. Are they
    issues for anyone?



    Anthony

  • Frank Finner

    #2
    Re: Whats missing from postgresql

    On 31 Mar 2004 17:00:52 -0800 anthony_barker@ hotmail.com (Anthony_Barker ) sat down, thought long and
    then wrote:
    [color=blue]
    > PostgreSQL does not offer the following key features typically
    > provided in enterprise databases(accor ding to Aberdeen):
    > _ Incremental and parallel backup/restore[/color]

    If you do several backup jobs for several databases on one engine at the same time, isn´t that
    "parallel backup"? But incremental would be really a nice thing for big databases.
    [color=blue]
    > _ Encryption (security)
    > _ Deadlock detection
    > _ Row-level locking (typically required by large packaged
    > applications) _
    > although PostgreSQL does offer alternative sub-table locking schemes
    > _ Bit-mapped indexing (for large data warehouses)
    > _ A single GUI administrative interface[/color]

    I would call PgAdmin such a thing.

    [color=blue]
    > _ View update/insert/delete
    >
    >
    > I was pretty sure that NETAPP offers incremental backup of Postgresql
    > - but perhaps I'm wrong.
    >
    > What about the row level locking or the other features. Are they
    > issues for anyone?
    >
    > http://www.sleepycat.com/aberdeenwp/
    >
    > Anthony
    > http://xminc.com/mt/[/color]

    What I am still _really_ missing is a simple reliable way for replication. I really would appreciate
    a good eager master-master-replication for failover purposes (eg. Heartbeat). Although once an
    Oracle consultant told me, that even for Oracle it is not simple and they do not recommend it. They
    prefer "lazy" replication.

    Regards, Frank.

    ---------------------------(end of broadcast)---------------------------TIP 1: subscribe and unsubscribe commands go to majordomo@postg resql.org

    Comment

    Working...