First of all, do you have an SMTP server running on your server? Does
it require authentication?
Depending on what you have and what you need to do, the mail() function
could work fine. With other situations you might need a package such as
Pear Mail to make things easier.
--
=============== ===
Remove the "x" from my email address
Jerry Stuckle
JDS Computer Training Corp. jstucklex@attgl obal.net
=============== ===
We are using 2 different Linux based servers: one for web (PHP, MySQL)
and another for the mail (Qmail, SquirrelMail e.t.c.). Our webserver
is co-located and mail server is installed here. For the PHP mail()
function to be able to use the mail server, I modified php.ini for
SMTP to pointi to the mail server' IP. Yet it still uses web server's
sendmail as SMTP MTA.
I have a question related to this post:
>
We are using 2 different Linux based servers: one for web (PHP, MySQL)
and another for the mail (Qmail, SquirrelMail e.t.c.). Our webserver
is co-located and mail server is installed here. For the PHP mail()
function to be able to use the mail server, I modified php.ini for
SMTP to pointi to the mail server' IP. Yet it still uses web server's
sendmail as SMTP MTA.
>
Please help
>
Did you define sendmail_path in your php.ini? Also, after changing your
php.ini, did you stop and restart your server?
What do you have for your sendmail parameters in your php.ini?
--
=============== ===
Remove the "x" from my email address
Jerry Stuckle
JDS Computer Training Corp. jstucklex@attgl obal.net
=============== ===
In article <1177680745.238 934.146880@s33g 2000prh.googleg roups.com>,
Max <MaximGolyuk@gm ail.comwrote:
>
>I have a question related to this post:
>>
>We are using 2 different Linux based servers: one for web (PHP, MySQL)
>and another for the mail (Qmail, SquirrelMail e.t.c.). Our webserver
>is co-located and mail server is installed here. For the PHP mail()
>function to be able to use the mail server, I modified php.ini for
>SMTP to pointi to the mail server' IP. Yet it still uses web server's
>sendmail as SMTP MTA.
>>
>Please help
>
That's not how UNIX email works. AFAIK, php.ini tells php where the
local mail transport agent (MTA) is located. php uses this to spawn a
thread or perhaps even fork() a process to deliver the mail to the MTA.
There's no provision to use "remote" MTAs.
>
You'll have to configure the local MTA on the web server to forward the
mail to the mail server if you want mail delivered.
Nonsense. PHP can just as easily use a third party SMTP server, as long
as it's configured properly, see Jerry's reply.
--
Rik Wasmus
Estimated date being able to walk again: 01-05-2007.
Less then a week, hurray!
In article <f0vppv$sft$1@n ews2.zwoll1.ov. home.nl>,
Rik <luiheidsgoeroe @hotmail.comwro te:
>Michael Vilain wrote:
>>That's not how UNIX email works. AFAIK, php.ini tells php where the
>>local mail transport agent (MTA) is located. php uses this to spawn a
>>thread or perhaps even fork() a process to deliver the mail to the MTA.
>>There's no provision to use "remote" MTAs.
>>>
>>You'll have to configure the local MTA on the web server to forward the
>>mail to the mail server if you want mail delivered.
>Nonsense. PHP can just as easily use a third party SMTP server, as long
>as it's configured properly, see Jerry's reply.
>
OK, I'll say it --slowly-- for you. AFAIK, php.ini won't allow
configuration to a REMOTE SMTP server on LINUX or UNIX systems.
Je m'excuse. Indeed the only hosts where I had to use a different SMTP
seem to be Windows hosts.... Where it's no problem to use a different one.
--
Rik Wasmus
Estimated date being able to walk again: 01-05-2007.
Less then a week, hurray!
I have read the php.net mail manual and am aware of the SMTP MTA
Windows redirect. The manual reads that php.ini SMTP string can be
configured for Windows servers only. I am aware of that. What I am
trying to accomplish is - to make it work in Linux setup.
Here is our scenario:
We have the following setup (I am rewriting the actual values for
security purposes):
The mail server's IP is 111.111.111.111 which resolves to
mail.mysite.com
The webserver's IP is 222.222.222.222 which is www.mysite.com or
mysite.com
To prevent increasing SPAM attacks we modified the Mail MX records to
point to our ISP, which has the SPAM filter installed on their server
(121.121.121.12 1). All the SPAM filter does is - it strips sender
email's domain part and verifying it with sender's IP. If it is a
match, then ISP's server relying it to our mail server
(222.222.222.22 2)
Webserver's sendmail is working properly, but what happens is:
111.111.111.111 -121.121.121.121 X 222.222.222.222
When the email is originated at 111.111.111.111 - mail.mysite.com
(using PHP mail() function), the ISP's filter reads the sender email
address, compares it with IP, arrests the email, replying "You are not
222.222.222.222 " and tries to bounce it back to 111.111.111.111 .
We need to bypass that route for mail originated on the webserver,
hopefully by rewriting php.ini.
I have tried rewriting php.ini, yet it did not produce desired
results.
Is there any other way, other than rewriting mail() function with our
own SMTP handler?
I have read the php.net mail manual and am aware of the SMTP MTA
Windows redirect. The manual reads that php.ini SMTP string can be
configured for Windows servers only. I am aware of that. What I am
trying to accomplish is - to make it work in Linux setup.
>
Here is our scenario:
>
We have the following setup (I am rewriting the actual values for
security purposes):
The mail server's IP is 111.111.111.111 which resolves to
mail.mysite.com
The webserver's IP is 222.222.222.222 which is www.mysite.com or
mysite.com
>
To prevent increasing SPAM attacks we modified the Mail MX records to
point to our ISP, which has the SPAM filter installed on their server
(121.121.121.12 1). All the SPAM filter does is - it strips sender
email's domain part and verifying it with sender's IP. If it is a
match, then ISP's server relying it to our mail server
(222.222.222.22 2)
>
Webserver's sendmail is working properly, but what happens is:
111.111.111.111 -121.121.121.121 X 222.222.222.222
>
When the email is originated at 111.111.111.111 - mail.mysite.com
(using PHP mail() function), the ISP's filter reads the sender email
address, compares it with IP, arrests the email, replying "You are not
222.222.222.222 " and tries to bounce it back to 111.111.111.111 .
>
We need to bypass that route for mail originated on the webserver,
hopefully by rewriting php.ini.
>
Max,
Looks like you need to change the rules on your mail server to accept
(and relay) mail from 111.111.111.111 .
--
=============== ===
Remove the "x" from my email address
Jerry Stuckle
JDS Computer Training Corp. jstucklex@attgl obal.net
=============== ===
Our mail server accepts emails from the webserver. Our emails are
going through default MX records, which point to our ISP server, which
does relay emails to our mail server. Simply put, I want to bypass the
MX record (which points to the ISP server's SPAM filter, which works
for us for all other mail, we have no control over)
On Apr 27, 9:30 pm, Jerry Stuckle <jstuck...@attg lobal.netwrote:
Max wrote:
I have a question related to this post:
>
We are using 2 different Linux based servers: one for web (PHP, MySQL)
and another for the mail (Qmail, SquirrelMail e.t.c.). Our webserver
is co-located and mail server is installed here. For the PHP mail()
function to be able to use the mail server, I modified php.ini for
SMTP to pointi to the mail server' IP. Yet it still uses web server's
sendmail as SMTP MTA.
>
Please help
>
Did you define sendmail_path in your php.ini? Also, after changing your
php.ini, did you stop and restart your server?
>
What do you have for your sendmail parameters in your php.ini?
>
--
=============== ===
Remove the "x" from my email address
Jerry Stuckle
JDS Computer Training Corp.
jstuck...@attgl obal.net
=============== ===
The sendmail_path in php.ini was commented out. I have uncommened it
and set the value to nothing. I did restart Apache after that.
Our mail server accepts emails from the webserver. Our emails are
going through default MX records, which point to our ISP server, which
does relay emails to our mail server. Simply put, I want to bypass the
MX record (which points to the ISP server's SPAM filter, which works
for us for all other mail, we have no control over)
>
In that case you'd have to look at your Unix/Linux configuration. PHP
knows nothing about MX records.
--
=============== ===
Remove the "x" from my email address
Jerry Stuckle
JDS Computer Training Corp. jstucklex@attgl obal.net
=============== ===
On Apr 27, 9:30 pm, Jerry Stuckle <jstuck...@attg lobal.netwrote:
>Max wrote:
>>I have a question related to this post:
>>We are using 2 different Linux based servers: one for web (PHP, MySQL)
>>and another for the mail (Qmail, SquirrelMail e.t.c.). Our webserver
>>is co-located and mail server is installed here. For the PHP mail()
>>function to be able to use the mail server, I modified php.ini for
>>SMTP to pointi to the mail server' IP. Yet it still uses web server's
>>sendmail as SMTP MTA.
>>Please help
>Did you define sendmail_path in your php.ini? Also, after changing your
>php.ini, did you stop and restart your server?
>>
>What do you have for your sendmail parameters in your php.ini?
>>
>--
>============== ====
>Remove the "x" from my email address
>Jerry Stuckle
>JDS Computer Training Corp.
>jstuck...@attg lobal.net
>============== ====
>
The sendmail_path in php.ini was commented out. I have uncommened it
and set the value to nothing. I did restart Apache after that.
>
True, I forgot - that's a Windows only parameter. For Linux you need
sendmail or sendmail substitute on your system.
--
=============== ===
Remove the "x" from my email address
Jerry Stuckle
JDS Computer Training Corp. jstucklex@attgl obal.net
=============== ===
Our mail server accepts emails from the webserver. Our emails are
going through default MX records, which point to our ISP server, which
does relay emails to our mail server. Simply put, I want to bypass the
MX record (which points to the ISP server's SPAM filter, which works
for us for all other mail, we have no control over)
"Jerry Stuckle" <jstucklex@attg lobal.netwrote:
: In that case you'd have to look at your Unix/Linux configuration. PHP
: knows nothing about MX records.
MX is pure DNS. It points to a mail server which usually opens port
25 up for SMTP and port 110 for POP3. PHP tends to run under an
Apache server which in turn opens port 80, unless one configures
weird/different things with port numbers.
Note, every IP address includes a port number, and a full connect
cannot be established without supplying the 5th element of the IP
address (the port number).
11.11.11.11:80 is a different IP address than 11.11.11.11:25.
When an SMTP server wants to relay mail to your mail server, it
issues an MX (DNS) query. PHP runs underneath Apache, but
I thought I read something somewhere that PHP can make and
accept connections on other ports. Perhaps, I'm getting it mixed
up with some Perl things I've read?
Anyways, that tends to be the way I think of it all. Please correct
me if anything I've stated is wrong.
Comment