Reading stdout and stderr separately

[ladygrinningsoul]

I have a Perl program which runs a number of external programs. I want to
be able to read both stdout and stderr into separate variables. The 'Perl
Cookbook' states (I quote):

To read both a command's STDOUT and its STDERR separately, it's easiest and
safest to redirect them separately to files, and then read from those files
when the program is done: system("program args 1>/tmp/program.stdout
2>/tmp/program.stderr" );


There has got to be a better way. Anyone?

[Joe Smith]

Re: Reading stdout and stderr separately

ladygrinningsou l wrote:
[color=blue]
> There has got to be a better way.[/color]

1) Look into IPC::Open3.
2) Next time, post to comp.lang.perl. misc (not comp.lang.perl) .

[Jürgen Exner]

Re: Reading stdout and stderr separately

ladygrinningsou l wrote:[color=blue]
> I have a Perl program which runs a number of external programs. I
> want to be able to read both stdout and stderr into separate
> variables. The 'Perl Cookbook' states (I quote):
>
> To read both a command's STDOUT and its STDERR separately, it's
> easiest and safest to redirect them separately to files, and then
> read from those files when the program is done: system("program args
> 1>/tmp/program.stdout 2>/tmp/program.stderr" );
>
>
> There has got to be a better way. Anyone?[/color]

Well, it's the same method as recommended by the FAQ. You did check the FAQ,
didn't you?

jue

[Alexey A. Kiritchun]

Re: Reading stdout and stderr separately

ladygrinningsou l wrote:
[color=blue]
>
> I have a Perl program which runs a number of external programs. I want to
> be able to read both stdout and stderr into separate variables. The 'Perl
> Cookbook' states (I quote):[/color]
[color=blue]
> There has got to be a better way. Anyone?[/color]

You should have read the book a little further. See recipe 16.9, (or at
least it is under that number in my copy), or jump straight to perldoc
IPC::Open3.

Using it is rather prone to deadlock, though.

If you are doing it as an excercise only, it is also posible to do
everything via fork(), exec(), and POSIX::dup().

--
Alexey 'Kaa the Snake' Kiritchun