Use of extern

[polas]

I have a quick question - I have used extern quite a bit in relation
to variables, however was wondering if its applicable to function
prototypes too?

For instance, I have a file called a.c - a small snapshot of it
contains

extern int a;
void hello(int);

Then in a file called e.c, a small snapshot I have

int a;
void hello(int num)
{
.....
}

These two C files are linked together during compilation, but is there
any reason to add extern in front of the hello function prototype in
a.c (or would adding this not conform to the standard.) On my C
compiler (gcc) it doesnt complain when I add extern in this way, but
doesnt seem to do a huge amount.

Cheers,
Nick

[Nick Keighley]

Re: Use of extern

On 24 Oct, 12:08, polas <n...@helpforce .comwrote:

I have a quick question - I have used extern quite a bit in relation
to variables, however was wondering if its applicable to function
prototypes too?

sort of

For instance, I have a file called a.c - a small snapshot of it
contains
>
extern int a;
void hello(int);
>
Then in a file called e.c, a small snapshot I have
>
int a;
void hello(int num)
{
....
>
}
>
These two C files are linked together during compilation, but is there
any reason to add extern in front of the hello function prototype

only for documentaion reasons

in
a.c (or would adding this not conform to the standard.)

adding extern to a function declaration does conform to
the standard

On my C
compiler (gcc) it doesnt complain when I add extern in this way, but
doesnt seem to do a huge amount.

correct.

function declaration
void hello(int);

function definition:
void hello(int n)
{
}

by default a function definition is has external linkage
(is "visible" throughout the program) if you put static
on the front it only has file scope (it is only "visible"
to the file it is definied in). Adding extern is the same as
not using static. Hence some people use extern on functions
and many do not. I don't use extern on functions.


--
Nick Keighley

"The quality I have in mind is all-absorbing,
not just a way of doing things but a way of being."

[Ben Bacarisse]

Re: Use of extern

polas <nick@helpforce .comwrites:

I have a quick question - I have used extern quite a bit in relation
to variables, however was wondering if its applicable to function
prototypes too?

Yes, but extern is the default for file-scope function declarations.
It is usual to omit it. You need it if you write a function
declaration at block scope but that is not commonly done.

--
Ben.

[Malcolm McLean]

Re: Use of extern


"polas" <nick@helpforce .comwrote in message news:

>I have a quick question - I have used extern quite a bit in relation
to variables, however was wondering if its applicable to function
prototypes too?
>

Ideally you'd have a hierarchy of exports so you could have a C source file
that was local to a library, but shared within the library.
Unfortunately you can't do this. extern is a bit like "auto".

--
Free games and programming goodies.

http://www.personal.leeds.ac.uk/~bgy1mm